Was Jesus God, Man, or Myth?
Some
biblical scholars question whether or not a historical Jesus ever
existed. Others are convinced that there was an actual Jesus although he
was fully human and did not perform miracles. And, of course, most
Christians believe that the entire Jesus story as told in the Bible is
completely true.
Read More:
Biblical scholarship is
a very complex field of study. One area of research delves into the
question of whether or not Jesus ever existed as man or god. I've been
researching this question and I'd like to layout the main reasons for
skepticism about the existence of Jesus. The arguments and evidence
could fill books—and they do—but I will just hit the highlights. I refer
you to the books for the details.
We cannot use the Bible as an historical reference since the Bible is what is being examined. Additionally, the Bible shows itself to be an unreliable document because it reports myth as truth, and even when dealing with known facts of history, geography, and science, it gets some of those facts wrong.
We cannot use the Bible as an historical reference since the Bible is what is being examined. Additionally, the Bible shows itself to be an unreliable document because it reports myth as truth, and even when dealing with known facts of history, geography, and science, it gets some of those facts wrong.
Is Jesus “mythologized history” or “historicalized mythology”?
If
we wish to know Jesus, the man, we must begin with the assumption that
Jesus is not divine, not the son of God, and had no supernatural powers
whatsoever. The question then becomes whether he was an actual person or
whether his existence is entirely myth.
Did a man named Yeshua ben Yousef live in Bethlehem during the first century of the Common Era? Did he preach, did he have disciples, and was he crucified? Putting aside the stories of the virgin birth, the miracles, and the resurrection, was there an actual historical Jesus?
Some scholars say Yeshua ben Yousef existed, but the stories about him are “mythologized history.” The story of his life was conflated with various mythologies current during his time. The books Zealot by Reza Aslan and How Jesus Became God: by Bart D. Erhman take this approach. They try to strip away the myth and show us the man.
Did a man named Yeshua ben Yousef live in Bethlehem during the first century of the Common Era? Did he preach, did he have disciples, and was he crucified? Putting aside the stories of the virgin birth, the miracles, and the resurrection, was there an actual historical Jesus?
Some scholars say Yeshua ben Yousef existed, but the stories about him are “mythologized history.” The story of his life was conflated with various mythologies current during his time. The books Zealot by Reza Aslan and How Jesus Became God: by Bart D. Erhman take this approach. They try to strip away the myth and show us the man.
No comments:
Post a Comment